5 Questions to Ask Before You Build Your Engagement Ring in Batavia IL

Creating an engagement ring should feel just as special as the moment it celebrates. At K. Hollis Jewelers in Batavia, we help you design a ring that reflects your love story by guiding you through the process of choosing the right setting, stone, and final touches.

Whether you're starting with a blank slate or bringing in ideas you've saved, our team is here to make the experience simple, meaningful, and fun.

As a family-owned, full-service jewelry store in Batavia, IL, we’ve helped thousands of couples create rings that are truly one-of-a-kind. If you're ready to start the design process, here are 5 important questions to ask:

1. What’s your partner’s style?

Before you think about diamonds, think about personality. Are they drawn to timeless and elegant looks? Something modern and edgy? Do they love sparkle, or prefer a clean and simple design?

Your partner’s style should guide every design choice, from the diamond shape to the setting.

2. Do you want a traditional diamond or something unique?

We offer a stunning collection of loose stones—including 49 brand-new lab-grown diamonds in unique shapes and cuts that are ideal for one-of-a-kind rings. And if you're looking for brilliance, our Centurion Collection features lab-grown diamonds with a 100-facet cut that radiates 40% more sparkle than traditional brilliant cut diamonds.

Prefer a natural diamond? We carry a beautiful selection of mined diamonds in timeless and trending shapes. Whether you're drawn to lab-grown or natural, we’ll help you find the perfect stone for your ring.

3. What metals and settings best match your lifestyle?

Think about how the ring will be worn every day. Some settings are low maintenance. Others are designed to stand out. We’ll help you explore your options, from platinum to yellow gold, and from solitaire to halo or hidden halo designs.

We’ll walk you through what lasts, what’s easy to care for, and what feels the most like “you.”

4. Do you want to incorporate heirloom stones or redesign a family piece?

We specialize in custom redesigns, especially when it comes to sentimental heirlooms. You can bring in your existing diamonds or gemstones, and we’ll help you design around them to make something new, beautiful, and filled with meaning.

5. What’s your timeline and budget?

Planning ahead makes the process smooth and stress-free. Whether you need something in a month or have time to dream it up over several, we’ll build your timeline around your needs and make sure you get the most value at every step.

We carry a wide selection of loose stones, settings, and designer styles that can be ordered or customized—so you don’t have to start from scratch. In fact, most of the engagement rings we create are built by pairing an in-stock or orderable setting with your chosen stone. That means you can design something meaningful and personal without waiting months for a fully custom process. Whether you’re working with a tight timeline, a specific budget, or a clear vision, we’re here to guide you every step of the way.

Real Words from a K. Hollis Customer:

"I had Brenda assist me with picking out an engagement ring and the customer service was outstanding. I was always updated on the status and they were able to rush an order through for me to get the ring on time. I will definitely be returning for future purchases. Thank you for all the help!" — Tyler Lang

Whether you're designing something new or building your ring from pieces we help you choose, we’re here to guide you every step of the way.

Come visit our Batavia showroom or book a consultation with our expert team. We’d love to be part of your story.